The CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck reverse number search engines are both good at identifying callers and catfishes, but differ in quality.
I ran some tests on CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck to help you pick the right number lookup tool. This is how it went. ⬇️
| CatfishNumber | ClarityCheck | |
| Personal details | Name, photo, address, etc. | Background checks |
| Telco data | Carrier and line type | Limited telco details |
| Global coverage | ✅ | ✅ |
| Speed & accuracy | Quick and highly accurate | Fast, somewhat accurate |
| Pricing model | Pay per lookup | Monthly plans + add-ons |
| Refunds | Simple, low commitment | Frequently reported issues |
| Customer support | Generally transparent | Often non-responsive |
What’s the Difference Between CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck?
The difference between CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck lies in their pricing practices and reliability of results.
– CatfishNumber’s prices are better for individuals than for companies. You don’t get multiple searches per plan, so you’re paying a small fee for each lookup.
– ClarityCheck has monthly subscriptions, which you can top up with more searches for a fee.
These plans are suitable for continuous lookups; if you’re reverse-searching only one number, ClarityCheck can be quite expensive.
Users complain about how hard it is to cancel or ask for refunds with ClarityCheck without getting Trustpilot involved. The accuracy can be inconsistent at times, too!
CatfishNumber vs. ClarityCheck: Comparing Features
CatfishNumber’s features focus on both the caller and the number, whereas ClarityCheck mainly looks at the caller’s identity.
- CatfishNumber: Identity + Telco Data
The CatfishNumber number lookup tool scans multiple databases (public, social, and proprietary) to find reliable, up-to-date details on phone numbers.
Personal details: CatfishNumber is great at identifying unknown callers – their real name, photo, address, and linked accounts (Twitter, Snapchat, Tinder, etc.).
Telco data: CatfishNumber verifies telco data, like the number’s carrier and line type. It works for VoIP numbers from sources like Google Voice or Hushed, too.
Anonymously search numbers from anywhere: the US, UK, Australia, India, Germany, and over 100 more countries. Number owners aren’t notified.
2. ClarityCheck: Background Checks + Identity
ClarityCheck, unlike CatfishNumber, runs background checks on the numbers searched but doesn’t focus on number details as much.
ClarityCheck claims to find a lot of personal caller details worldwide, including legal info: it scans sex offender lists, but only within the US.
Other than that, this tool lists registered vehicles and finds the basics (name, photo, address, accounts, and age).
What CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck have in common is their speed and risk score system. Also, neither of them has API access like Lookify.
Which Has Better Pricing: CatfishNumber or ClarityCheck?
As someone who doesn’t typically need to search numbers, I’d say that CatfishNumber has the better pricing plans, whereas ClarityCheck is pay-to-win.
CatfishNumber does not have subscriptions. Users pay for however many number lookups they need or want:
- 2 lookup credits for $6.95
- 5 lookup credits for $11.95
This makes it easier to opt out if you change your mind because you don’t have to commit to a monthly or yearly plan and waste the remaining searches.
It’s not a free tool like NumLookup, but CatfishNumber doesn’t force users to pay more to unlock the full results. Very transparent, which I like!
ClarityCheck offers monthly and one-time payments. The monthly plan costs $29.99/mo and includes 20 number lookups.
A 7-day trial is available for $3.99. Alternatively, you can pay for a small number of searches without subscribing monthly.
- 10 credits for $24.99
- 25 credits for $49.99
- 50 credits for $89.99
That’s going to hurt the pocket, for sure. To access Sex Offender Databases and enable Unlimited PDF Downloads, you have to pay for separate plans.
Are CatfishNumber or ClarityCheck Results More Recent and Accurate?
The results from the CatfishNumber report were more recent and accurate, not to mention higher in number. But ClarityCheck didn’t disappoint either.
– The CatfishNumber Test:
I tried different phone numbers on CatfishNumber because I wanted to test its global reach. Safe to say, I am impressed.
In all instances, results included personal info: full name, photo, address, and associated accounts. Links were also included and fully functional.
I got the number’s telco info as well: which company issued the phone number, whether it’s landline, mobile, or VoIP, and its risk level.
But hey, numbers from big countries are easy to find, right? I tested a number from a small European state, and to my surprise, CatfishNumber got it right:
I like how organized the CatfishNumber report was and how many platforms and useful details were present. The accuracy gets a 10/10 from me.
– Testing ClarityCheck:
ClarityCheck was pretty decent! Again, I tried it with different numbers just to keep things fair, and the results were plentiful.
It correctly identified the number owner, but a few minor details were off (some usernames and emails). Otherwise, the real name and address were spot-on.
I didn’t see the profile photo, which I consider crucial data. Neither the vehicle nor the complete list of socials was there. I’d understand a free tool like SpyDialer doing this, but not a paid one.
ClarityCheck isn’t the best at detecting VoIP usage; however, the report was easy to read and filled to the brim with intel.
Where Do CatfishNumber and ClarityCheck Fall Short?
CatfishNumber could use a trial model as a testing phase. Their current plans work for personal use, but not companies that reverse-search numbers daily.
And I think ClarityCheck is pricey – 30 bucks a month for only 20 searches?! This makes it non-optimal for both casual and professional searchers.
Then the additional credits on top of it come to an extra $30-$90. So it doesn’t have CatfishNumber’s low-commitment plans or Melissa Lookup’s bulk searches.
❌ Not to mention ClarityCheck’s “sneaky” billing policies. It prices the one-week trial at $3.99, yet makes automatic additional charges on people’s accounts.
Oh, but don’t worry, you can cancel anytime…or so they promise. In reality, they rarely help users who reach out for refunds.
The ClarityCheck support team only seems to respond when they see people escalating the issue online or on Trustpilot. Not the best PR strategy.
Purchasing something online is already anxiety-inducing, and for ClarityCheck to cleverly overcharge its clients is a huge red flag.
Leave a Reply